By: Carl Coates

October 12, 2026 — The candy may be free, but everyone has their own list of Halloween losers. Maybe it’s candy corn, Smarties, or the black licorice flavored Good & Plenty. For me, it was Milk Duds. I just didn’t get it. A mildly chocolate-flavored coating of a rather bland caramel ball whose other main ingredient, besides sugar or corn syrup, was clearly some anti-saliva agent that would require significant time and effort to break down. At some point, the amber chunk would soften to something that could be swallowed or at least get stuck in your teeth so you could move on to something tastier.  

children showing off their Halloween haul back at their house
The author’s children post candy swap. The increase in utility is real.

But one person’s Milk Duds is another’s Kit Kat, and the Halloween candy swap is a highlight of the year for many children, their first taste of the thrill of the trading pit. Visit a cafeteria lunch table in early November, drop into a sleepover soon after Halloween or, in the case of my own children, immediately after getting home from Trick-or-Treating, you can observe the all-important inventory count followed by some strategic trading.  

A pillowcase full of candy is a random bundle, and it’s bound to include some personal (Milk) duds. That mismatch leaves value on the table, and trading is how kids win it back. When two kids agree to a swap, both walk away better off by their own measure, or they wouldn’t have agreed.  

In their study on children’s intuitions about trade, Echelbarger, Good and Shaw cite studies in which pre-school children exhibit behaviors suggesting an ability to place differential value on certain objects and an unwillingness to share objects they favor. By five years old, children can incorporate factors related to supply and demand to infer about an item’s desirability.

In their own study, when children were made aware of a potential trading partner’s preference, they predicted that partner would accept an unbalanced swap in order to obtain their preference. Children in this study, ages 5-10, were therefore sensitive to preference in trading contexts and also understood there are limits. The more lopsided the trade, the less likely they thought it would happen: a chocolate lover might give up two cookies for one chocolate, but three was a harder sell. As the researchers stated, “these results suggest that children can integrate information about preferences and cost…when making decisions about which trades an agent is likely to accept or reject.” 

If 8-year-old me announced “Milk Duds! Yuck!” this study suggests that kids would correctly predict what happens next: my trading partner would hold out for more Milk Duds before parting with their Kit Kat. Ultimately, whether they get two or four milk duds, we both come out ahead. The ratio just decides who gets the bigger share of the gains. 

Through trick-or-treating, children receive random gifts from neighbors, providing varying degrees of personal utility. Finding potential trading partners to jettison less favored candy with the return of more favored candy is optimizing behavior at its finest.  Kids don’t just trade; they instinctively grasp that trades happen because people value things differently. That’s what generates voluntary exchanges that move candy to the kids who value it most. 

How Voluntary Exchanges Minimize Deadweight Loss 

Many economists have researched the valuation of gifts. In this context, valuation means how much a gift is worth to the recipient, measured in dollar terms, as opposed to what the giver spent on it.  

And the economists have not reached consensus. Waldfogel argued that a recipient values the gift less in dollar terms than the cost the giver paid, often resulting in deadweight loss (a loss in economic value that benefits no one). Solnick and Hemenway surveyed a broader population than Waldfogel and found recipients valued gifts well above cost. List and Shogren used auctions to show that recipients often valued gifts more than they reported on the surveys.  

Whether or not gifts waste value on average, candy swapping shows how voluntary exchange moves goods to the people who value them most. 

Given the random distribution of candy that ends up in one’s bag, there’s likely some deadweight loss. If one could survey the candy givers (aka, your generous neighbors) about their expenditure on the candy and compare it to the value kids place on their Halloween sweets, there would be some differential suggesting the price paid for the candy was more than the value the kids got from it. But some kid out there longs for Milk Duds the way I long for Kit Kats. So, the deadweight loss exists because each kid’s duds landed in the wrong pillowcase, not because the duds lack value. 

However, if we surveyed kids before and after a candy swap, the value they place on their candy should increase. The total amount spent on the candy of interest is the same. No new candy actually exists. And yet the value increases. Without a trade, kids would end up throwing away someone else’s favored candies. That represents vanishing value that nobody benefitted from, or deadweight loss. Clearly, such exchanges successfully move candy to the kid who values it most. And, by extension, removes, or at least decreases the deadweight loss. 

Markets Find a Way 

Research on how children trade shows awareness developing early. From early ages, children are aware of their own preferences and keenly observe others’.  Adam Smith spoke of humans “propensity to truck, barter, and exchange one thing for another” in The Wealth of Nations. Visit a department store after Christmas and observe all the people returning gifts. This is like an adult version of the candy swap.  

One of economist Greg Mankiw’s 10 principles of economics is: Markets are usually a good way to organize economic activity. Nobody planned who ends up with what, yet candy swaps help candy flow toward the kids who value it most. A useful contrast is to imagine a parent trying to reallocate everyone’s candy. The parent would need to know every kid’s tastes, which the kids themselves are much more aware of. Markets work because prices and trades put scattered private knowledge to use. 

When given an opportunity to trade candy, children willingly part with their yucks to acquire some more yums. Not only does this improve their haul but helps redistribute these scarce goods in a way that moves total value closer to an optimal level. In other words, by acting in our own self-interest, we facilitate a decrease in deadweight loss. These voluntary exchanges are all around us. Shoppers move along, and acquire, old clothes and accessories through Depop, Vinted and Poshmark. We seek out tickets to sporting events and concerts on secondary market sites like SeatGeek and StubHub. Halloween candy swaps remind us that trading is all-too-human. 

For the record, I never did learn to like Milk Duds, and I never had to. I just had to find the right kid who did. 

arrow-downarrow-leftarrow-rightarrow-upcaret-downcaret-leftcaret-rightcaret-upcheckmarkclosefacebookInstagramlinklinkedinlong-arrow-leftlong-arrow-right-thinlong-arrow-rightlong-arrow-upmagpauseplay-solid-roundplayresource-download-largeresource-downloadresource-external-largeresource-externalresource-internal-largeresource-internalresource-videoreturnXYouTube